November 14, 2014
The Avocado Opinion Dept. Waiver and Pledge
Please READ Before Continuing
By continuing to read this article (words on a page), I understand that any and all content contained below (see “words on a page”) has been fabricated (made up) by our writers (people who make things up) for the purpose of entertainment (satire, comedy, or the author’s need as a human to kvetch). I agree (see “say yes”) not to take anything the Avocado Opinion Dept. (Dan D.’s staff of people who “make stuff up”) has written (again, “made up”) as fact and admit (again, say “yes”) that as a consumer (person who takes things in) of news media (people wearing makeup on TV or the Internet who tell events to you in a generally biased manner) I (you) ought to cross check stories ( the words on a page thing) before accepting them and/or erupting invective (“writing mean things about people”) on a comments section (hell on earth).
![](https://i0.wp.com/thumb7.shutterstock.com/display_pic_with_logo/1507895/155100011/stock-vector-little-pony-155100011.jpg)
What if I were to tell you that children get some of their values from a cartoon show? You probably would not bat an eye. In the 1980’s,
G.I. Joe had
public service announcements to warn kids about drugs.
Captain Planet had
similar PSA’s for pollution and environmental awareness. Even the
Sonic the Hedgehog TV series had a segment called
“Sonic Sez”, where SEGA’s spiky blue mascot tries to teach kid viewers some life lessons with his animated pals.
So far, pretty “normal”, right?
What if I were to tell you that adults are learning values of generosity, selflessness, teamwork and tolerance from a cartoon show? A bit out of the ordinary, but not too strange.
Pixar movies are made for all ages. Children are drawn in by colorful characters and amusing stories; adults pick up on the more mature jokes and pop culture references.
Still with me? Because here’s where things get bizarre.
Did I lose you?
If that threw you for a loop, you are not alone. Even I had a hard time believing that one — even as a self-appointed aficionado of strange pop culture phenomena.
At first you might think this is a joke. How could mostly grown-up guys like a show made for girls in grammar school? More importantly, how can these dudes be legitimate fans in a purely un-ironic way? This is precisely the question that the movie,
Bronies: The Extremely Unexpected Adult Fans of My Little Pony (2012) tries to answer. In this documentary, a handful of “Bronies” — the moniker these men have taken — are interviewed about the significance of the cartoon program and how there lives have been shaped by it.
In the United States, a teenage male – approaching adult age, and from the sticks – is hazed and threatened by the rednecks in his town for embracing the show. His segment is more a look at intolerance and gender norms. A slightly younger boy from a conservative family “comes out” as a Brony to his parents. This boy attempts to win over his traditional father who has a hard time expressing his feelings, like any other macho patriarch.
Overseas, a young chap from the UK with Aspergers Syndrome is also a big fan of the program. He takes the show’s lessons and applies them to make sense of the complex real world. Just as he uses
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic (2010) to connect to other human beings, an adult couple in Germany uses the show to bond with one another. She watches the show with her boyfriend, sings the songs with him and even makes her own small horses to sell at “
BronyCon“.
BronyCon is a convention where all the fans of the show meet and share the love for all things Pony. Voice actors Tara Strong (who plays the lead character, “Twilight Sparkle”) and John de Lancie (a prominent villain, “Discord”) showed up to meet the fans and bring a few new people into the herd. The show’s creative developer, Lauren Faust, surprised everyone by shedding some tears after receiving a standing ovation from the fans.
The most interesting part of the documentary occurs during an interview with a psychologist about why adults would watch a children’s television series. She said something I found very intriguing (I’m paraphrasing, of course): in a post-9/11 world, these adult men are finding comfort in a pink world of magic, rainbows and sparkles. It’s a retreat to a more innocent time of childhood, perhaps. Society seems to frown upon the Brony movement because it may make men out to be weak and feminine when men are supposed to be “hunters” and “providers”.
Before watching this film, my attitude was one of mockery and superiority; after viewing it, I learned to have more tolerance for a subculture that is misunderstood. Who am I to judge? I like to attend Comic-Con’s and cosplay as superheroes. Hell, just a few weeks ago I bought a season of
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles on DVD. We never stop being kids at heart. What society has a problem with is the age and gender that fit a certain norm for media consumption.
My personal view on the Brony phenomenon is two-fold. I am all for anything that:
1) Encourages people to be creative,
and
2) Doesn’t harm anyone, in any way.
For many graphic artists and musicians, the Brony movement is a muse that inspires them to make colorful fan art. DJ’s, songwriters, cartoonists and painters have been able to share what they love with others who will appreciate their skills and talents.
The positive values the show promotes are necessary in a world full of cut-throat capitalism and violence. Who cares why grown men have decided to be more caring and feminine? I’ll tell you who: the patriarchy. If the greed and aggression men are supposed to have dissipates, what does that mean for a (American, in this instance) society where competition is placed above coexistence? What if we should ALL become more caring individuals?
I will point out that there is a dark side to the Brony movement when the show is viewed from a more perverse and sexual frame of mind. However, if someone uses this as a reason to bash the whole Brony fanbase, I would bring up the internet’s “Rule 34”. If it exists, there is porn of it. Don’t let the actions of a few perverts ruin something that is mostly a force for positivity.
Curtis M. Parvin is a Rhode Island-based writer and filmmaker. His Twitter link is in his byline above; here is his IMDB page.